Correcting Two Income Tax Myths



At ICAN we see a lot of tax returns when we help a student with a FAFSA.  As an ICAN advisor, we are not tax experts, but we do become familiar with tax information in relation to students as dependents in connection with parents’ tax returns.  There are two myths I would like to address.

First, many parents believe that if they claim their children as a dependent on their parent tax return, the child cannot file a tax return for themselves.  This is not true.  Even is a student is claimed as a dependent on their parents’ tax return, the student can still file their own tax return.   If a student works a part-time job and has $400 in federal withholding withheld from their paychecks in a year and they have no tax liability, the student can file a tax return (probably a 1040EZ) and receive the $400 back if they had no liability.  The student cannot claim a personal exemption for themselves (the student) and the parent also claim the student as a dependent.  But yes, the student can file a tax return, and should file, to recover the withholding from their paychecks.  That is the student’s money that is withheld, and they should file a tax return to get it back.

Second, many parents believe that on the FAFSA the student is a dependent or independent student based on whether the student is claimed or not claimed as a dependent on the parent tax return.  This is not true. A dependent student on the FAFSA requires that parent information is reported on the FAFSA, and an independent student means the student does not report parent information on the FAFSA.  Parent information would include income and assets of the parent(s). Whether the student is a dependent or independent student on the FAFSA is based on the dependency questions on the FAFSA not on a tax return.

I hope this clears up some misunderstanding that has been going on.  Happy income tax and FAFSA filing!



Steve - ICAN Council Bluffs Center